I understand the appeal of putting Buy Now on a collection page. If someone wants the product, why make them take two extra steps? I’d ask one question before building it: can they tell what they’re about to buy from the card alone?
Think about a shopper reordering a familiar box of tea. They know the pack, they know the size, and they may want to add it while they’re still looking for something else. Add to Cart works well there. Now imagine I’m new to the brand and I’m deciding between loose leaf, tea bags, and a refill. Going straight to checkout may just mean I have to go back and check what I picked.
Sometimes the right button is Choose Options
Shopify’s accelerated checkout can take a shopper directly to checkout for a single product. Its Dawn reference theme also demonstrates a different approach: add an eligible product from its card or ask the shopper to choose options first. I’d use those as starting points. For a single-product campaign with a clear offer, I’d be happy to test Buy Now. For a subscription or a bundle with important choices, I’d give those details room on the product page.
What I’d ask marketing to measure
I’d agree on the outcome before the test starts. If checkout starts rise but completed orders per session stay flat, we may have moved people to a different screen without helping more of them buy. I’d also look at basket value and watch for wrong-variant corrections. When there’s enough traffic, I’d look at new and returning customers separately. A shortcut for someone who already knows the catalogue might be confusing to someone seeing it for the first time.
